The author had supported most of his claims with primary sources and left many links to those. Surrounded by aides and journalists, soviet premier nikita. Commissar, 19181945 pdf kindle hallo readers have you read the book memoirs of nikita khrushchev, volume 1. My new book, trotskys amalgams, discusses some of trotskys lies that have fooled people, and demoralized honest communists, for. The new kiev legislation is not the first attempt aimed at equating communism and nazism. Having looked at the arguments presented by the contents, i would say that it is not accurate and generally a work of sensationalism, although. The numbers show that the ussr cant have had more than 5 million domestic casualties during stalins time imo. Grover furr, new light on old stories about marshal. In this book, grover furr answers the central questions concerning the mass repressions known as the ezhovshchina or, by anticommunists, the great terror. Some western communists deny that joseph stalin was the murderous dictator he is extensively documented as having been their motivation stems from standard my enemys enemy logic, combined with the idea that the revolution required and requires a strong leader, and stalin fits that bill. One can understand praise for josef stalins positive contributions which in fact are many, no doubt, but one cant digest open defence of not simply mistakes but of the organised repressions and physical eliminations by stalin and his group in the course of the history of the. Grover furr began studying russian language and literature as a teenager and became interested in soviet history about a decade later.
The first is that, had furr written a similar book in any area of. Stalin, describes the monumental 1930s villainy of nikolai yezhov, head of the nkvd. A pathetic defence of stalinist repressions mainstream weekly. Khrushchev lied grover furr pdf ijbrary of confess catalcguinginpublicalion daa furr, cirover c. Commissar, 19181945 pdf kindle today for those of you who have not read the book pdf memoirs of nikita khrushchev, volume 1. In 1974 a newlydiscovered document from these files was examined by british historian frederick l.
Ilya erenburg, answer to a letter, in russian original and english translation, transcribed and with an introduction by grover furr pdf. From the soviet union of nikita khrushchev to todays. They hate grover furr because he is an honest researcher in an age filled to the brim with propaganda. While it is true that the soviets carted german documents by the train load to moscow where they only became available in the 1990s and now arent so available anymore due to government policy in russia at the moment, the files of the german intelligence agency most likely responsible for. In it, researchers found evidence that leon trotsky deliberately lied many times and about many people and events. He has conducted extensive research on the stalin period of soviet history, on and off since the 1970s, and intensely for the past decade.
Grover furr has spent a decade studying the flood of documents from formerly. One can understand praise for josef stalins positive contributions which in fact are many, no doubt, but one cant digest open defence of not simply mistakes but of the organised repressions and physical eliminations by stalin and his group in the course of the. Open library is an initiative of the internet archive, a 501c3 nonprofit, building a digital library of internet sites and other cultural artifacts in digital form. Cambridge university press, 1987, 121 grover furr, evidence of leon trotskys collaboration with germany and japan, 32 ibid, 3839. Jan 12, 2014 by alfonso casal there are certain assumptions one can make, with a high degree of certainty, regarding grover furrs khrushchev lied. They hate grover furr because he has evidence for the conclusions he draws and presents it openly, rather than relying on emotionalism. In the spelling of russian names, i have adhered, by and large, to the transliteration system of the library of congress, without the soft sign and diacritical marks. Translated and edited by strobe talbott with a foreword by edward crankshaw and an introduction by jerrold l. Copyright 2009 by grover furr and cultural logic, issn. Grover furr has agreed to answer some of our questions. Grover furr on nikita khrushchevs secret speech youtube. Reference to a party commission under the control of the central committee presidium.
The evidence that every revelation of stalins and berias crimes in nikita khrushchevs infamous secret speech to the 20th congress of the communist party of the soviet union on february. While some of the charges khrushchev made have long been rejected in the west and in russia, for example the idea that secret police chief lavrenty beria was a foreign agent, many other. The mods will choose the best 10 questions and i will email them to prof. Grover furr has performed a valuable service to the field of soviet studies by grappling in depth with nikita khrushchevs secret speech of 1956.
To further add on why furr is talking bullshit here. The evidence that every revelation of stalins and berias crimes in nikita khrushchevs. Stalin is the first accurate account of the socalled great terror in the soviet union in 19371938. May 06, 2017 the numbers show that the ussr cant have had more than 5 million domestic casualties during stalins time imo. Although rather amusingly he suggests on the same page that khrushchev possibly had the soviet archives purged of references to trotskys guilt. Uncritical reading and the discourse of anticommunism. Trotskys lies what they are, and what they mean posted on january 27, 2017 leave a comment the personality and the writings of leon trotsky have long been a rallying point for anticommunists throughout the world. Review of grover furrs khrushchev lied by alfonso casal on january 12, 2014 0. The evidence that every revelation of stalins and berias crimes in nikita khrushchevs infamous secret speech to the 20 th congress of the communist party of the soviet union on february.
American professor and author of books and articles in russian and english on soviet history under the period of joseph stalin, partic. Khrushchev lied is the american title, and the book was just announced on a small publisher. Part ii days of disaster, the final victory and a surprising admission. The global connections foundation, which evolved from an international awarenessbuilding program established in 1999, is a. We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. As far as i can tell, this book attempts to argue with khrushchevs secret speech and exonerate stalin. Grover furr evidence of leon trotskys collaboration with. The author had supported most of his claims with primary sources and left many links to those sources in his book so you can look them up online. Grover carr furr iii born april 3, 1944 is an american professor of medieval english literature at montclair state university, but is best known for his books and articles on the history of the ussr under joseph stalin, particularly the 1930s. A pathetic defence of stalinist repressions mainstream. The evidence that every revelation of stalins and berias crimes in nikita khrushchev s infamous secret speech to the 20th party.
The author of khrushev lied the evidence that every revelation of stalins and berias crimes in nikita khrushchevs infamous secret. The first is that, had furr written a similar book in any area of historical specialization other than sovietera studies, khrushchev lied would be immediately hailed as a work of major significance. Grover furr evidence of leon trotskys collaboration with germany and japan part i if an objective research project on the events of those years were to be done, free of ideological dogmas, then a great deal could change in our attitude towards those years and towards the personalities of that epoch. Khrushchev lied by grover furr a leaflet with his story, picture, vrover a call for german soldi to desert to the soviet side, was produced. But during the 1930s trotsky deliberately lied in his writings about joseph stalin and the soviet union. By equating ussr to nazi germany west covers up own. March 8, 1963 in music, as in other arts, there are many genres, styles and forms. Memoirs of nikita khrushchev volume 3 statesman 19531964 edited by sergei khrushchev memoirs translated by george shriver supplementary material translated by stephen shen. Welcome to grover furrs home page montclair state university. Furrs book, khrushchev lied attacked the speech given by nikita. The truth about mass repressions and the socalled great terror in the ussr yezhov vs. Jan 25, 2019 discover book depositorys huge selection of grover furr books online. Grover furr talk on his book khrushchev lied youtube.
Nikita khrushchev, declaration on music in soviet society. Surrounded by aides and journalists, soviet premier nikita khrushchev 1894 1971 left laughs as he holds up a corn cob during a visit to the farm of american farmer and businessman roswell garst 1898 1977 right, facing camera, coon rapids, iowa, september 23, 1959. Mar 20, 2017 grover carr furr iii born april 3, 1944 is an american professor of medieval english literature at montclair state university, best known for his books on joseph stalin and the soviet union. Grover furr montclair state university originally published in russian historyhistoire russe, nos 23 summerfall 1986, 293308. The personality and the writings of leon trotsky have long been a rallying point for anticommunists throughout the world. Grover furr is a crank case and a genocide denialist. Commissar, 19181945 epub immediately visit our web to just read the memoirs of nikita khrushchev, volume 1. Grover furr has performed a valuable service to the field of soviet studies by grappling in depth with nikita khrushcheva s secret speech of 1956. If youve been living under a rock and dont know who prof. Grover furr is frequently referred to as a fringe academic and is lambasted for having prostalinist commitments. Originally published in pravda, september 21 1948, this is the famous soviet jewish writers criticism of zionism. They hate grover furr because he challenges the bourgeois anticommunist understanding of soviet history.
New light on old stories about marshal tukhachevskii. Grover furr is a professor at montclair state university who has spent a great deal of time researching the history of the ussr in the years between the world wars. Incidentally, i have done the same kind of thing concerning bukharin. Institute for international studies brown university providence rhode island the pennsylvania state university press university. There are certain assumptions one can make, with a high degree of certainty, regarding grover furrs khrushchev lied. Grover carr furr iii born april 3, 1944 is an american professor of medieval english literature. Grover carr furr iii born april 3, 1944 is an american professor of medieval english literature at montclair state university, best known for his books on joseph stalin and the soviet union. Grover furr has spent a decade studying the flood of documents from formerly secret soviet archives published since the end of the ussr. Review of grover furrs khrushchev lied the red phoenix. By equating ussr to nazi germany west covers up own shameful.
The innocence of marshal tukhachevskii and the other military commanders condemned with him in 1937 has become firmly accepted by both soviet and western historians. Jun 10, 2016 they hate grover furr because he is an honest researcher in an age filled to the brim with propaganda. Erythros press and media, llc, kettering, ohio, usa. Then he broke old precedents, traveling far and wide.
The russian government flat out admitted in 2010 that the katyn massacre was indeed committed by the nkvd, and the causes of the holodomor are not generally disputed by most of the educated world outside of russia. Lo storico statunitense grover furr a proposito del dibattito su stalin tra domenico losurdo e nicolas werth in english. He opens the second session of the ecumenical council in rome. The evidence that every revelation of stalins and berias crimes in nikita khrushchevs infamous secret speech to the 20th party. Discover book depositorys huge selection of grover furr books online.
I have recently known of him and he seems interesting. Exceptions have been made a when other spellings have become more or less conventional peter kropotkin, leo tolstoy, alexander herzen. Other evidence of trotskys lies comes from his own writings and in documents from former soviet archives. Khrushchev on music in soviet society seventeen moments. From the soviet union of nikita khrushchev to todays russia. Khrushchev lied is certainly a very detailed and thorough book in the sense that it goes in detail to refute every implication and argument khrushchev makes. Nov 09, 2001 grover furr is the author or khrushchev lied. As far as i can tell, this book attempts to argue with khrushchev s secret speech and exonerate stalin. It is a shibboleth of anticommunism, whether liberal, conservative, russian, western, etc. We must give credit to the allies in the rubble of stalingrad, red army infantrymen moved forward in 1943 to finish off the nazi sixth army. Note in the spelling of russian names, i have adhered, by and.
1364 332 222 799 1520 391 1619 823 421 160 166 1029 945 1265 531 401 1607 928 334 1026 63 20 1442 216 118 1185 519 1071 686 1517 707 185 795 1017 62 829 1135 1448 1217 969 830 1300 1171 769